Nicholas Layton is appealing Herefordshire Council’s decision to refuse planning permission
In December 2025, Herefordshire Council refused planning permission for the proposed erection of and the construction of an Anaerobic Digestion (AD) plant at Whitwick Manor, Lower Eggleton, Ledbury, Herefordshire, HR8 2UE – planning application 222728/N.
– Too big for the location
– Detrimental effects to landscape
– Adverse effect to River Wye SAC
The council’s delegated report for refusal is here, and the main points are listed below.*
Save the Wye vigorously campaigned to raise objections to this application for a vast, industrial-scale anaerobic digester (AD) plant in open countryside near Yarkhill, Herefordshire (the area of 27 football pitches) to process chicken muck from miles around using untested technology they claimed would strip the nutrients from the manure. ‘Wrong technology in the wrong place’. Wrong technology as ADs do not breakdown phosphates, one of the major pollutants of the Wye. Wrong place – it should be in an industrial zone, not the open countryside.
We are therefore extremely concerned that the appellant, Nicholas Layton, is appealing Herefordshire Council’s decision to refuse planning permission. You can find the document we received to notify us of the appeal here.
The inquiry start date is 6 October 2026
Appeal reference number: 6010475
Planning application reference: 222728
Herefordshire Council link to case and all appeal documents here
Timetable
Statements from the local planning authority and any Rule 6 groups: Due by 12 August 2026.
Interested party comments: Due by 12 August 2026.
There are a huge number of documents relating to the appeal.
We have prioritised this list as the most important:
Non Tech Summary
Advance Notice of Costs
Statement of Common Ground
Statement of Case
Also useful:
Sustainability Credentials
Downstream effects of nutrients
Submit a response by 11.59 pm Wednesday 12 August 2026 on this link:
https://appeal-planning-decision.service.gov.uk/comment-planning-appeal/appeals/6010475
Make your response count!
The inquiry will start at 10 am on 6 October 2026 – the location is still to be confirmed. Anyone can submit a response before the inquiry (using the link above), attend the inquiry and ask to speak, but the inspector can exercise discretion in allowing you to speak.
For everyone who has already written a response to Herefordshire Council to the original planning application, Herefordshire Council’s notice of appeal states, “We have forwarded all the representations made to us on the application to the Planning Inspectorate and the appellant. These will be considered by the Inspector when determining the appeal“. However, if you have read the recently submitted appeal documents and would like to add new material, raise new points or reiterate your response, please do not hesitate to do so before 11.59 pm on Wednesday 12 August 2026 on this link https://appeal-planning-decision.service.gov.uk/comment-planning-appeal/appeals/6010475. Equally, if you did not submit a written response originally, you can make a response to the appeal on this link by midday 12 August. If short of time, we recommend you start with the Statement of Case.
Your comment should:
- Quote the Appeal reference number 6010475 – Whitwick Manor, Lower Eggleton, Ledbury, HR8 2UE
- State that your response is an objection (or in support)
- Reference relevant planning policies eg.
- Herefordshire Local Plan Core Strategy 2011–2031
- Yarkhill Neighbourhood Plan: https://www.herefordshire.gov.uk/media/fblpfokb/neighbourhood_development_plan_june_2018.pdf
- UK environmental laws and regulations
4. State if your response is AI generated (apart from simply looking things up).
Further information about taking part in a planning appeal inquiry can be found here: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/planning-appeals-dealt-with-by-an-inquiry-taking-part/guide-to-taking-part-in-planning-and-listed-building-consent-appeals-proceeding-by-an-inquiry
*Herefordshire Council – Planning permission refused on these four points:
1. By virtue of its scale, throughput and function, the development falls within the definition of a large treatment facility as described in Policy W5 of the Herefordshire Minerals and Waste Local Plan. Policy W5 establishes a clear spatial strategy for the distribution of waste management facilities within the County of Herefordshire, requiring large scale facilities to be located within the designated strategic employment areas. The application site is neither allocated nor identified as such and instead occupies an undeveloped agricultural field in the open countryside with no functional relationship to an established employment location. The proposal therefore fail to comply with the locational requirements of Policy W5 of the Herefordshire Minerals and Waste Local Plan (2024).
2. The proposed large scale anaerobic digestion facility and associated commercial grain store are not considered to accord with Policies RA6 and E1, which direct larger-scale employment-related development to appropriate strategic employment sites and require rural development to be commensurate in scale with the rural location and setting. The scheme represents a stand-alone industrial-scale facility with only limited connection to the surrounding rural economy and does not constitute a diversification of an existing agricultural enterprise. Accordingly, the proposal is contrary to Policies W5 of the Herefordshire Minerals and Waste Local Plan 2024, Policies RA6, SD2 and E1 of the Herefordshire Local Plan – Core Strategy Policy Y4 of the Yarkhill Neighbourhood Development Plan (2018) and the plan-led approach required by paragraph 15 of the National Planning Policy Framework.
3. The proposed development, by virtue of its scale, massing and industrial form, together with the associated operational activity, would result in a contrasting and visually intrusive complex in an area that is currently characterised by a rural agricultural landscape. The digesters, tanks, grain store and associated infrastructure, together with the engineered wetland areas and extensive soil bunding, would introduce large-scale built features wholly uncharacteristic of the prevailing landscape character.
Furthermore the proposed mitigation measures, including woodland planting and the constructed bund, are not considered to successfully integrate the development into the landscape; the bund in particular would read as an artificial and incongruous form that does not reflect the natural topography or field structure of the locality.
The scale and nature of the proposal represents an inappropriate form of development that would cause demonstrable harm to the character, appearance and perceptual qualities of the landscape, including views from nearby public rights of way and rural lanes. The proposal therefore conflicts with Policies SS6, LD1, RA6 and SD2 of the Herefordshire Local Plan Core Strategy, Policies Y11 and Y12 of the Yarkhill Neighbourhood Development Plan and Section 15 of the National Planning Policy Framework which together require development to conserve and enhance landscape character, integrate sensitively with its surroundings, maintain local distinctiveness and be of a scale appropriate to its rural setting.
4. The Local Planning Authority is unable to conclude, beyond reasonable scientific doubt, that the proposed development would not result in an adverse effect on the integrity of the River Wye Special Area of Conservation (SAC), either alone or in combination with other plans and projects, as required by the Conservation of Habitats and Species Regulations 2017. The Council’s Appropriate Assessment (dated 24 September 2025) identifies that there remains uncertainties and lack of completeness on the aerial incombination effect test which prevent a legally robust conclusion that impacts relating to water quality, aerial emissions (including ammonia), and the deposition of nitrogen and acidifying pollutants would be avoided or fully mitigated.
In the absence of certainty that no adverse effect on the integrity of the River Wye SAC can be secured, the proposal conflicts with Policies SS6, LD2 and SD4 of the Herefordshire Local Plan – Core Strategy, which require the protection of international ecological designations and the prevention of development that would undermine water quality objectives. The proposal also fails to comply with paragraph 185 and Section 15 of the National Planning Policy Framework, which require that significant harm to biodiversity is avoided, mitigated or, as a last resort, compensated for, and that planning permission must be refused where such harm cannot be ruled out.